This month · The State of Injustice is Pennsylvania

The Record November 2026
A floodlit classical capitol at dusk, wet pavement, flags still against a dark sky.

Last Month's State of Injustice · Florida · September 2026

In Florida, the Constitution Does Not Apply

Twenty-six years after Apprendi, the state's enhancement machine still finds the facts that lock the sentence — by a preponderance, without a jury, and, as of this spring, without a court willing to hear the merits.

The Pen Champions newsroom · Tallahassee — · 28 min read

In the State of Florida, a jury may convict a person of a crime beyond a reasonable doubt, and then sit down. What happens next is not sentencing in the constitutional sense. It is a second trial, held without a jury, under a lighter burden, about facts that often have nothing to do with how the offense was committed — the accused's status, a release date, a prior strike, an acronym that turns a range into a wall.

Prison Releasee Reoffender. Habitual Felony Offender. Habitual Violent Felony Offender. Violent Career Criminal. PRR, HFO, HVFO, VCC. Four ways of saying the same thing: the prosecutor will allege something extra, a judge will find it more likely than not, and the court will lose the power to be a court.

The United States Supreme Court has spent a quarter century saying this is not how a sentence is supposed to be built. A year before Apprendi, Jones v. United States (1999) had already said that any fact increasing the maximum penalty must be treated as an element — and charged as one. In Apprendi v. New Jersey (2000), the Court held that any fact that increases the penalty beyond the statutory maximum must go to a jury, be proved beyond a reasonable doubt, and appear in the accusatory pleading. In Alleyne v. United States (2013), it said the same of any fact that raises a mandatory minimum. In Erlinger v. United States (2024), it said a jury, not a judge, must decide whether prior offenses were committed on separate occasions.

Florida has heard all of this. Florida has not obeyed it.

This is not a metaphor. It is the supremacy clause. Article VI makes federal law "the supreme Law of the Land," and the "Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding." If a state's sentencing scheme lets a judge find, by a preponderance, the facts that lock a sentence to the statutory maximum and strip the bench of discretion, that scheme is not a local preference. It is a refusal.

Pen Champions does not come to this as a think tank. We do the work the bar largely will not: post-conviction investigation and collateral attack, in a system that has almost no lawyers assigned to check whether the last lawyer, or the last court, did the job. We write this month's State of Injustice because Florida is not merely harsh. Florida is, on this point, extra-constitutional.

The enhancement machine

Florida's recidivist and reoffender statutes do not ask the jury what it found. They ask the judge what the state can show.

The Prison Releasee Reoffender Act, § 775.082(9), Florida Statutes, is the cleanest illustration. If the state proves that a defendant committed a qualifying felony within three years of release from a correctional institution, the court must impose the statutory maximum. Not up to the maximum. The maximum. There is no downward departure worth the name. There is no youthful-offender off-ramp once the designation sticks. The sentence is not a judgment. It is an output.

The facts that trigger PRR are not the elements of the crime of conviction. They are status facts: that the person was in prison, that the person was released on a particular date, that the new offense fell inside a three-year window, that the new offense is on a list. A jury that has just decided guilt has decided none of this. Under the statute as administered, it is not asked to.

HFO, HVFO, and VCC — the habitual and career provisions of § 775.084 — work the same grammar. Prior convictions, dates, the "separate occasions" question, the violent or qualifying character of old cases: the prosecutor alleges them in a notice; the court finds them, typically by a preponderance of the evidence, often on a scoresheet and a packet. Then the range moves, or the floor becomes the ceiling, or both.

The jury is allowed to decide the primary offense. After that, the state files a new set of allegations — not about how the crime was committed, but about who the person is said to be.

Call it what it is. Those allegations manufacture a minimum mandatory. They take the judge's discretion and put it in the state's pocket. The prosecutor becomes, in the old and accurate phrase, judge, jury, and executioner of the sentence.

This is not an accident of drafting. It is the point. A legislature that does not trust juries to be severe, and does not trust judges to be severe, will write a statute that lets the charging office finish the case after the Constitution is done with it. Florida wrote several.

What Apprendi actually held

Apprendi was not a technicality. Charles Apprendi pleaded to a weapons offense that carried a five-to-ten-year range. A New Jersey statute let the judge add two years if the judge found, by a preponderance, that the crime was a hate crime. The Supreme Court reversed. "Other than the fact of a prior conviction," Justice Stevens wrote, "any fact that increases the penalty for a crime beyond the prescribed statutory maximum must be submitted to a jury, and proved beyond a reasonable doubt."

The progeny closed the obvious exits.

  • Jones v. United States (1999): a fact that increases the maximum penalty is an element. It must be charged.
  • Apprendi v. New Jersey (2000): other than a prior conviction, any fact that increases the penalty beyond the statutory maximum must be submitted to a jury, proved beyond a reasonable doubt, and charged in the accusatory pleading.
  • Blakely v. Washington (2004): the "statutory maximum" for Apprendi purposes is the maximum a judge may impose solely on the facts in the verdict or the plea — not the absolute cap in the code.
  • United States v. Booker (2005): the rule reaches the federal guidelines.
  • Cunningham v. California (2007): a state scheme that gave judges the upper term on extra facts cannot stand.
  • Alleyne v. United States (2013): facts that raise a mandatory minimum are elements. Harris is overruled.
  • Erlinger v. United States (2024): whether prior offenses occurred on separate occasions is a jury fact.

Florida's answer, for years, was a shrug dressed as doctrine: PRR does not "increase" the maximum, it merely requires it; the release date is "ministerial"; prior convictions live in the Almendarez-Torres exception; and even if there was error, it was harmless, because a jury would have found the same facts anyway, or because the sentence still sits "within the range."

Each of those answers is a way of not answering. A statute that converts a discretionary maximum into a mandatory sentence has raised the floor to the ceiling. The person has been deprived of the only thing a sentencing court is for — judgment. Harmless-error analysis that treats "within the range" as the end of the inquiry treats the loss of all discretion as a rounding error. It is not.

A court has no authority to call a facially unconstitutional statute harmless. Harmless error is a doctrine about trials. It is not a pardon the judiciary may grant itself for keeping an invalid law on the books year after year. Florida has been doing this for twenty-five years. Twenty-six. The violations do not become smaller with age. They become a method.

Taylor, 97-CF-23932: five arguments the court would not hear

The file is old. The challenge is not.

State v. Taylor, No. 97-CF-23932, is a 1997 Florida case. The Prison Releasee Reoffender sentence it produced has been sitting on that docket ever since. What is new is the post-conviction challenge recently put in front of the court: five arguments that had not previously been brought before it. Fundamental error required the court to take the merits. The court ignored the merits anyway.

That is the method. Not a ruling that the arguments fail. A refusal to say whether they fail. Then, later, the claim that they were already decided.

Five arguments never before put to the court. Fundamental error required the merits. The court declined to read them.

One. The information never charged PRR.

The circuit court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction to impose a Prison Releasee Reoffender sentence under § 775.082(9). The information filed in Taylor contained no allegation whatsoever that the defendant qualified as a PRR. It did not allege any fact establishing that the offense occurred within three years of release from a qualifying prior incarceration. The omission is fatal. A court does not acquire power over an enhanced penalty by silence.

Two. A fact that raises the sentence is an element, and an element must be charged.

This is not a Florida novelty. Jones v. United States, 526 U.S. 227 (1999), recognized that any fact increasing the maximum penalty must be treated as an element that needs to be charged. Apprendi v. New Jersey, 530 U.S. 466 (2000), held that — other than the fact of a prior conviction — any fact that increases the penalty beyond the prescribed statutory maximum must be submitted to a jury and proved beyond a reasonable doubt, and it emphasized that such facts must be charged in the accusatory pleading. Blakely v. Washington, 542 U.S. 296 (2004), closed the definitional exit. Alleyne v. United States, 570 U.S. 99 (2013), extended the rule to mandatory minimums. A charging document that never names the fact cannot support the sentence the fact produces.

Three. Without PRR, the Criminal Punishment Code still had a ceiling.

Absent the PRR designation, Taylor would have been sentenced under the Florida Criminal Punishment Code. Without aggravating factors pled or proven, and without written findings justifying a departure, the sentence would have been constrained by the guidelines. It could not lawfully exceed what the base offense authorized. By triggering PRR, the state took him entirely out of the guidelines framework and imposed a mandatory term that far exceeded what could have been imposed without those aggravators and those written findings. The enhancement did not sit "within the range." It destroyed the range.

Four. Status is not the offense — and a later notice is not a charge.

PRR is not a mere sentencing factor tied to how the current offense was committed. It is a completely separate allegation about the defendant's status and the timing of a prior release. Because it has nothing to do with the manner of the current offense, it functions as an element of an aggravated form of the crime, and it must be formally charged.

Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.140 requires that each count allege the essential facts constituting the offense charged. A charging document silent on the facts necessary for the actual punishment imposed fails to invoke the court's authority over that enhanced penalty. Florida's own habitual-offender line already said as much: Massey v. State, 589 So. 2d 336 (Fla. 5th DCA 1991), approved, 609 So. 2d 598 (Fla. 1992); Ashley v. State, 614 So. 2d 486 (Fla. 1993). Notice, and a chance to contest the enhancement, are constitutionally required. The state's practice of filing a separate notice of intent after the information — or of leaning on a generic Department of Corrections warning signed years earlier — does not satisfy that requirement. A warning is not a charge. A later notice is not an element.

Five. The statute fires the judge.

Once the state pursues PRR and "proves" eligibility by a mere preponderance of the evidence, the trial court is stripped of all sentencing discretion. The judge is required by statute to impose the exact mandatory maximum. That mandate does not merely harden a sentence. It transfers traditional judicial sentencing power to the prosecutor, and it deprives the judicial branch of its constitutional role as a check on the legislative and executive branches. Judicial discretion in sentencing has historically been the safeguard that made a sentence a judgment rather than an output. By eliminating that discretion entirely through a mandatory scheme triggered by uncharged facts, the PRR statute violates separation of powers under Article II, Section 3 of the Florida Constitution.

Because the court never acquired jurisdiction over the PRR-enhanced penalty, the portion of the sentence imposed under the statute is void. A judgment or sentence entered without jurisdiction is a nullity. It is a facially unconstitutional application of the statute. It may be attacked collaterally at any time, without regard to time bars or retroactivity. See Crane v. State, 767 So. 2d 1240 (Fla. 2d DCA 2000).

That is the claim recently raised in Taylor. Five arguments. None of them previously before the court. Fundamental error — the rule that a defect going to the validity of the sentence must be reached even if it was not perfectly preserved — required the court to address the merits. The court did not. The merits were ignored. The sentence, built on an information that never charged the facts that locked it, remains.

Florida courts have a practiced reply. They will say the issue was decided, or was available, or is successive, or is not cognizable in the vehicle you used. They will say Florida case law has "addressed" enhancement challenges, as if a citation to a case that did not decide your facts were a decision on your facts. They will refuse the merits and then tell you the merits are settled. In Taylor, they did not even have that excuse. The arguments had not been brought before. The rule still required a ruling. They declined to give one.

That is not adjudication. It is exhaustion as a method.

Watch the sequence, because it is the sequence we see on the inside of files, not in press releases. A person raises the constitutional claim. The court declines to take the merits — even when fundamental error says it must. The next court says the last court already disposed of it. A later motion is "successive." Direct appeal is long gone. The sentence — the one the information never charged, the one the jury never found — becomes a fact of nature. The person is told, in the patient language of procedure, that the United States Constitution had a deadline.

Maye v. State: the door closed on purpose

On May 14, 2026, the Supreme Court of Florida decided Maye v. State, No. SC2023-1184.

Marcus Roland Maye was convicted of robbery with a deadly weapon in 2002 and sentenced to a mandatory life term as a Prison Releasee Reoffender. In a motion under Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.800(a) — the rule that lets a court correct an illegal sentence at any time — he argued that the PRR statute is unconstitutional both facially and as applied under Apprendi and Alleyne: a judge, not a jury, found by a preponderance the facts that locked him to life.

The court, in an opinion by Justice Francis, did not decide whether he was right.

It held that an Apprendi claim is not an "illegal sentence" claim under Rule 3.800(a), because Apprendi errors are subject to harmless-error review. It receded from Plott v. State (2014), which had allowed such claims in that vehicle. The sentence stands. The statute stands. The merits wait.

The State of Florida, in the same case, conceded that if the challenge were properly raised, the PRR statute is unconstitutional under Erlinger. The majority noted the concession and walked around it. Judicial restraint, the court called it. Erlinger, it added, is not retroactive.

Were Maye's challenge to the PRR statute properly raised, the State concedes that Florida's PRR statute is unconstitutional under Erlinger.

Maye v. State, No. SC2023-1184 (Fla. May 14, 2026)

Justice Labarga dissented. Twenty-four years of "unambiguous directives" from the United States Supreme Court, he wrote, and the majority had used the harmless-error rule and the choice of vehicle to dispose of the case without facing the Constitution. "There is no greater rule of law in our country than the Constitution of the United States."

Read the holding twice. A person serving a mandatory life sentence under a statute the State will not defend on the merits is told: you used the wrong envelope. The envelope that is supposed to be available "at any time" is not available for this. Direct appeal is long gone. A 3.850 motion has a clock. Harmless error is declared to apply to a statute that, every year, removes the jury from the facts that make the sentence and removes the judge from the power to sentence.

That is not a technicality. That is a system that has decided the Constitution is a filing problem.

Maye did not only say the facts had to go to a jury. He said the statute, as it stands, is facially invalid. The courts have no authority to call a facially unconstitutional statute harmless error. Harmless error is for a trial that went wrong. It is not a standing permission slip for a law that goes wrong every time it is applied. Apply that permission slip "indefinitely" — twenty-five years, twenty-six — and you have not found error harmless. You have found the Constitution optional.

Judge, jury, and executioner

Follow the power.

The jury decides the primary offense, or a lesser included, under the burden the Constitution actually requires. Then the prosecutor files notice of PRR, or HFO, or HVFO, or VCC. The court holds a hearing that is not a trial. The standard is preponderance. The facts may be a release date, a pairing of old cases, a qualifying-list match. If the finding is made, the statute speaks: the maximum is required, or a mandatory minimum appears, or every downward path is closed.

Who sentenced the person?

Not the jury. The jury was sent home.

Not the judge, not in any sense that "judge" still means a person who may judge. Discretion is gone. The statutory maximum is not a ceiling the court may approach. It is a required occurrence. The finding that produces it was made on a burden the Constitution does not allow for facts that move a sentence.

The prosecutor alleged the extra facts, chose the enhancement, and now owns the sentence. That is the fusion the separation of powers is supposed to prevent. It is also the fusion Apprendi was written to prevent: the state may not, by calling a thing "sentencing," take elements away from the jury.

Florida has spent a generation insisting that these facts are not elements. The United States Supreme Court has spent a generation saying that if they move the sentence, they are. The state's own lawyers, in Maye, would not defend the statute against Erlinger. The state's highest court would not say the word.

Until Florida's courts will hear that on the merits — not as a vehicle, not as harmless error, not as a case they already "addressed" — the United States Constitution does not apply in the State of Florida. Not in the sentencing hearing. Not in the post-conviction unit. Not in the life of the person who will serve every day of a maximum the jury never authorized.

The tricks that keep the merits off the page

If you have litigated these claims from the inside, you already know the catalog. If you have not, it is worth writing down, because the catalog is the holding in slow motion.

  • Refuse the merits. Call the claim unpreserved, successive, or not cognizable in the motion that was filed — even when fundamental error requires the court to reach them.
  • Cite Florida cases that "addressed" enhancement challenges without addressing the argument actually raised.
  • Treat a release date, a window, or a qualifying-list match as "ministerial," as if the fact that a clerk can look it up meant a jury need not find it.
  • Apply harmless error because the sentence is "within the range" the statute itself created — using the invalid law as proof that the invalid law did no harm.
  • When the United States Supreme Court closes another exit, wait, then say the new decision is not retroactive, and that the old vehicle is the wrong one anyway.

None of this requires a finding that the person is guilty of the extra facts beyond a reasonable doubt. That is the tell. A system confident in its facts would try them. A system that needs the sentence more than it needs the verdict will keep the second trial in chambers.

What this month requires

The State of Injustice is a monthly brief. It is also a description. We will move it, state by state, because the failure is not only Florida's. This month the pin is in Tallahassee.

Pen Champions is not waiting for a better vehicle. We do post-conviction work because that is where the sentence actually lives — after the trial lawyers have gone, after the direct appeal has been "affirmed without comment," after the person inside has become the only one still reading the record. There are not enough lawyers on that side of the wall. There never were. The people who have been run through the system are, often, the only investigators left.

If you have a Florida enhancement — PRR, HFO, HVFO, VCC — that was found by a judge on facts a jury never saw, and never charged, you are not raising a novelty. You are raising the question Maye was not permitted to finish, the five questions Taylor (97-CF-23932) just put on the table, and the question Apprendi answered in 2000.

The supremacy clause is not optional. A state does not get to usurp the federal rule by calling the usurpation procedure. A prosecutor does not get to be the whole court. A statute that guarantees the maximum is not a range. And a constitutional violation that the state will not defend, and the court will not reach, is not harmless. It is the state of injustice.

This month, it is Florida. Next month it will be another jurisdiction that has decided the jury's work ends where the sentence begins. The file will change. The pin will move. The record will not.

This brief is reporting and analysis by Pen Champions, not legal advice. Citations in the margin can be updated in the state file without touching the rest of the site.