This month · The State of Injustice is Pennsylvania

The Record November 2026
A long, dim public corridor.

The State of Injustice · Pennsylvania · November 2026

In Pennsylvania, Every Car Is a Suspect

Thousands of license-plate cameras now line the Commonwealth's roads. Every pass is logged, stored and searchable by police across the country — and Pennsylvania still has no law that says when to stop.

The Pen Champions newsroom · Harrisburg — · 12 min read

An automated license plate reader does not wait for a crime. It photographs every vehicle that passes, reads the plate, stamps it with a time and a place, and uploads it to a database that police can search later. The ACLU of Pennsylvania puts it plainly: the data "allows people to be tracked for as long as the data is retained." [ACLU-PA]

The largest seller of these cameras is Flock Safety. Pennsylvania is where its network has quietly become a statewide grid.

The grid

In September 2026 testimony to the House Transportation and Judiciary committees, the ACLU of Pennsylvania cited an Electronic Frontier Foundation dataset reporting that more than 450 law enforcement agencies in the state use license plate readers. Citing Finding Flock and Axios, it reported 3,759 documented cameras statewide — the ninth-largest total in the country — including 1,444 in 59 cities, with Pittsburgh highest at 266, and 2,315 outside city limits, with Allegheny County highest at 827. [ACLU-PA testimony]

NBC10 found that Flock alone operates more than 2,700 license-plate cameras across Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Delaware. [NBC10] Volunteer mapping lists Flock and other plate readers in more than twenty Chester County municipalities, from Tredyffrin to Coatesville to Phoenixville. [MyTownView / DeFlock]

The cameras are not just numerous. They are connected. A camera on one township's road becomes a query result for a department hundreds of miles away.

A city of two cameras, searched eleven million times

The Pennsylvania Capital-Star filed Right-to-Know requests for Flock records with six police departments. Allentown and Bethlehem denied them, citing the criminal-investigation exemption. Only New Castle, in Lawrence County, turned over its audit logs. [Capital-Star]

What they showed: from January 2024 through June 2026, other agencies around the country ran more than 11 million searches of New Castle's Flock data. New Castle's own officers ran just over 10,000. The city has two Flock cameras. More than four in five searches listed no case number. Nearly 36,000 were labeled "test." Other agencies gave "immigration" or "ICE" as the reason for thousands of searches. [Capital-Star]

An analysis by Footnote4a of New Castle's Flock event log, obtained through the same records process, found that the department's plate reader, a pan-tilt-zoom camera and 29 acoustic sensors all sit in or beside one census tract — the only one in the city where white residents are not a majority. Officers added 99 plates to private watchlists; 95 carried no case number, and 28 were set never to expire. The log records more than 300 network shares extending access to over 100 agencies in Pennsylvania and Ohio. [Footnote4a] [MuckRock records]

Flock says it has no business relationship with ICE and that federal sharing is off by default, but individual departments may turn it on. [Capital-Star] Nationally, 404 Media documented more than 4,000 lookups by local and state police on Flock's network with immigration-related reasons or done for federal authorities. [404 Media]

Chester

Chester is a predominantly Black city of about 32,500 in Delaware County. [The Trace] Volunteers have mapped 21 license plate readers inside city limits — 4.3 per square mile, denser than 85 percent of the U.S. cities indexed. Only one is tagged as a Flock unit; the maker of the other twenty is not recorded. [Finding Flock] [How You Are Tracked] These are community-mapped points, not an official inventory; Chester has not published who owns each camera or how its data is shared.

The question of who gets watched in and around Chester is not abstract. In 2021, seven Black residents of neighboring Chester Township sued in federal court, alleging that the same officer arrested them for "loitering" outside their own homes within ten days in 2019. The charges were dismissed by the Delaware County District Attorney for lack of evidence. The suit alleged the township's police disproportionately stopped Black residents. [WHYY] [Inquirer]

PEN Champions contends that in Chester, plate readers are concentrated on and used against communities of color. The public record does not yet allow that to be measured: no Chester-area department has released its audit logs. In New Castle, where the logs were released, the cameras sat in the city's one majority-minority tract. That is why the logs matter.

Chairman Birdsong

Paul Birdsong is the chairman of a Black Panther Party group that began patrolling Chester in February 2026, after Philadelphia police revoked his and several members' licenses to carry firearms. The group says its mission is to protect residents from gun violence, drug dealing and heavy-handed policing. [The Trace] [Delco Times] In Philadelphia he had led the Black Lion Party for International Solidarity. [Axios] The Justice Department's Civil Rights Division later opened an investigation into whether Philadelphia police revoked gun licenses without proper cause; that filing did not name Birdsong. [Inquirer]

On July 11, 2026, a Chester officer stopped Birdsong downtown. According to the criminal complaint reported by Axios, the officer wrote that police had been gathering "intelligence" on Birdsong after previous encounters and knew of his pending Philadelphia license case before the stop. Police said one of his two handguns was mostly concealed in a pocket; Birdsong says both were holstered in plain view. He was charged with carrying a concealed firearm without a license, resisting arrest and disorderly conduct, and held on $75,000 bail. [Axios] In September a magisterial district judge dismissed the resisting-arrest and both disorderly-conduct counts and held the firearms count for trial. [Inquirer] Birdsong says the enforcement was racially motivated: "They're arresting us as an effort on their part to bully us, to scare us." [Inquirer]

On Aug. 28, 2026, Chester police arrested William Ozah, a PEN Champions co-founder. Court dockets list two charges, both dated that day: evading arrest or detention on foot, a second-degree misdemeanor, and disorderly conduct, a summary offense. No knife or weapons charge was filed. Bail was set at $25,000, and on Sept. 22 both charges were held for court. [Commonwealth v. Ozah, MJ-32121-CR-0000250-2026; CP-23-CR-0003480-2026, Delaware County]

Four days after the arrest, on Sept. 1, Delaware County opened an extradition case against Ozah. PEN Champions says it rests on a Maryland probation warrant (St. Mary's County, 18-K-15-000093) issued Sept. 3, and that the Chester arrest is what triggered it. On Oct. 21 the court dismissed the fugitive complaint. [In re Ozah, CP-23-MD-0002509-2026]

According to PEN Champions and witnesses, a Flock camera had just been placed facing the entrance to Ozah's house shortly before his arrest, and it was moved right after. Witnesses photographed the camera. PEN Champions has public records requests pending on when and why it was installed. PEN Champions is also looking into whether any Pennsylvania state law enforcement agency, and not only the Chester City police, had any involvement in these events; that question remains open. These accounts have not been independently verified. PEN Champions challenges the arrest as unconstitutional.

According to PEN Champions, Flock cameras were used to track Chairman Birdsong's movements, and that tracking led to his arrest and to the arrests of several other members of the Chester chapter. PEN Champions contends that three of those members were arrested unlawfully, and that the charges that followed were pretextual — aimed less at public safety than at securing convictions that would strip members of their Second Amendment right to bear arms. The published charging documents describe an officer who "recognized" Birdsong and an "intelligence" file built on him; they do not say what tools built it. Chester police have not publicly said whether plate-reader data was used. That is exactly the kind of question an audit log answers — and exactly the kind of record Pennsylvania departments have refused to release.

Who is pulling the plug, and who is not

Abington Township is trying to break its Flock contract early, citing data-security problems, and approved Axon cameras to replace it. Its new policy keeps non-investigative data for 30 days — longer than Flock's new seven-day default and the 48 hours the ACLU recommends. [Inquirer] Munhall Borough told the Office of Open Records that its Flock cameras have been removed. [OOR, Bard v. Munhall] Residents are using the Right-to-Know Law to demand camera locations, contracts and sharing records, as in a pending appeal against Wright Township. [OOR, Niewinski v. Wright Twp.]

The ACLU of Pennsylvania's legislative director, Elizabeth Randol, told NBC10 the cameras "are not discerning between the people who are criminals and who are alleged to have committed a crime, or innocent people," and said she would support a ban. [NBC10]

House Bill 2771

On Oct. 19, 2026, the House passed HB 2771, sponsored by Rep. Jennifer O'Mara, 190–13. It would limit government use of plate readers to serious criminal investigations, stolen vehicles, missing persons, registration and inspection enforcement, parking and secured-area access; require deletion of non-relevant data within 72 hours; ban sale and sharing of captured data; and open audit logs to the Right-to-Know Law while keeping plate data closed. [PA House] [RTKL Decisions] The ACLU of Pennsylvania supports it. [ACLU-PA]

On Oct. 26 the Senate sent it to its Transportation Committee. The session ends Nov. 30 with only a few Senate voting days left; if the bill is not enacted, it dies and must start over. [PA General Assembly] [CNHI]

What this month requires

Last month the pin was in Tallahassee, where the courts let a judge find the facts that lock a sentence. This month it is Harrisburg, where no one has to find any fact at all before the state records where you went. The Fourth Amendment was written against general warrants. A camera that logs every car, shares it with eleven million searches, and asks for a case number one time in five is a general warrant with a power cord.

Call your state senator before Nov. 30 about HB 2771. File a Right-to-Know request for your department's Flock audit log. And if plate-reader data was used against you in a case, write to us.

This brief is reporting and analysis by Pen Champions, not legal advice. Statements attributed to Pen Champions are our contentions; linked sources support the remaining facts.